Dog Toothpaste: The No-Nonsense US Guide to Enzymatic, Natural, and VOHC-Accepted Picks

Dog Toothpaste: What It Actually Does (and What It Doesn't)

Dog toothpaste is not a mouthwash for dogs. It is a delivery system for friction, flavor, and — in some formulas — enzymes or calcium peroxide that slow the plaque film from hardening. The brush does the heavy mechanical work. The paste makes the brush tolerable and, in the best cases, adds a chemical assist that keeps working after you put the brush down.

That distinction matters because the US market is crowded with tubes that use the word “enzymatic” the way cereal boxes use “natural.” It sounds like a guarantee. It is not. An enzyme name on a label does not tell you the concentration, the stability of the enzyme in the tube, or whether the finished product has been tested. The only third-party check that currently separates marketing from evidence for a specific plaque or tartar claim is the Veterinary Oral Health Council (VOHC) seal — and toothpaste is surprisingly rare on that list.

Most dogs over three years old already have some evidence of periodontal disease, according to the AVMA. Brushing is the single most effective home-care step between professional cleanings, and daily is the benchmark. A tube of paste is not a substitute for that routine, a veterinary exam, or an anesthetic cleaning when tartar has already calcified. It is the thing that makes the routine repeatable. If the dog hates the taste, you lose. That is the real selection criterion.

Why Human Toothpaste Is a Bad Idea — Xylitol, Fluoride, and the Swallow Problem

The short answer to “can you use toothpaste on a dog” is no. Not the human kind. The longer answer is that human toothpaste is built for a creature that spits. Dogs do not spit. They swallow, and the ingredients that make human paste pleasant — fluoride, sodium, foaming agents, and sometimes xylitol — are not designed for a stomach that cannot rinse.

Xylitol is the ingredient that turns a mistake into an emergency. It triggers a rapid insulin release in dogs and can cause hypoglycemia, seizures, and liver failure. The FDA's veterinary center is blunt about it: only use pet toothpaste for pets, never human toothpaste. Fluoride is less immediately dramatic in small accidental tastes, but a large ingestion can cause gastrointestinal and electrolyte problems, and no dog should be deliberately given fluoride paste to swallow. The foaming agents are a milder issue, mostly because they taste terrible to dogs and make them fight the brush.

Here is the part that gets skipped on a lot of pet blogs: “fluoride-free” on a human toothpaste label does not make it dog-safe. A fluoride-free human paste can still contain xylitol, sorbitol, artificial sweeteners, or essential oils that irritate a dog's mouth. The safe default is a product labeled for dogs, used according to its directions. That is not corporate caution. It is the difference between a paste that is designed to be swallowed in small amounts and one that is designed to be spat out.

Baking soda deserves its own warning. It is a common DIY ingredient and a common label claim, but the Veterinary Centers of America explicitly advises against using plain baking soda as a toothpaste alternative for pets. Its alkaline content can upset the stomach and digestive tract, and it tastes awful. A small amount inside a formulated dog toothpaste is a different thing from a spoonful of Arm & Hammer from the pantry.

The Types of Dog Toothpaste That Exist in the US Market

The category splits along two axes: how the paste claims to control plaque, and how it tries to get the dog to accept the brush. Most confusion comes from mixing those two up. A peanut-butter flavor is a compliance feature, not a cleaning technology. An enzyme system is a cleaning claim, not a guarantee of palatability.

Enzymatic toothpaste

Enzymatic dog toothpaste contains enzymes intended to support plaque control beyond the abrasive action of the brush. The most transparent example in the US market is Virbac C.E.T., which names glucose oxidase and lactoperoxidase. In that system, glucose oxidase helps generate hydrogen peroxide from glucose, and lactoperoxidase uses that peroxide with thiocyanate to support an antimicrobial environment. Whether that translates into a visible difference depends on daily use, the dog's mouth, and the brush reaching the gum line.

The label word “enzymatic” is not standardized. Some products name a specific enzyme, some describe a “dual-enzyme system,” and some use the word without disclosing the system at all. Petful's comparison makes the point cleanly: Virbac discloses the dual-enzyme system, Vet's Best names glucose oxidase, and Arm & Hammer and Sentry Petrodex describe their products as enzymatic without the same level of accessible detail. That does not make the quieter labels bad. It means the word alone is not evidence.

Non-enzymatic and calcium-peroxide formulas

Petsmile Professional is the clearest non-enzymatic contrast. Its Calprox formula uses calcium peroxide and minerals rather than a glucose oxidase system. The finished product carries a current VOHC acceptance for plaque on the dog list, which is a stronger statement about the exact product than simply recognizing an ingredient name. The practical takeaway: a non-enzymatic paste can hold the best third-party evidence in the category, and an enzymatic paste can hold a very clear formula disclosure without holding the seal. Those are two different virtues.

Natural, organic, and baking-soda options

“Natural” and “organic” are not safety certifications. RADIUS sells a USDA Organic canine toothpaste made with coconut oil, sweet potato, and cinnamon, free from xylitol, fluoride, and synthetic preservatives. That is a legitimate niche for an owner who wants a short ingredient deck. It is not automatically more effective than a conventional paste, and the USDA organic seal speaks to agricultural sourcing, not to plaque reduction in a dog's mouth.

Baking soda appears in Arm & Hammer's dental line as a label ingredient, usually paired with enzymes. The brand positions it around breath and tartar control. The evidence boundary stays the same: baking soda on a label does not by itself prove superior plaque control, and Arm & Hammer Complete Care is not on the current VOHC dog toothpaste list. It is a budget-friendly tube that many dogs accept. That is a real benefit. It is not a clinical claim.

Flavor matters more than the label

Poultry is the default for a reason. Mint is a human preference that many dogs reject, and a minty paste that gets used twice and then abandoned is worse than a plain poultry paste that gets used daily. The US market runs on chicken, beef, peanut butter, vanilla-ginger, coconut, and the occasional novelty like London broil. Nylabone's peanut flavor and Arm & Hammer's vanilla-ginger are compliance plays, not cleaning technologies, and that is fine. The best dog toothpaste is the one that survives contact with a suspicious terrier on a Tuesday night.

Best Dog Toothpaste: 7 Picks Ranked for 2026

This is not a “top rated dog toothpaste” list built from star averages. Star averages measure whether a dog tolerated the flavor for two weeks. The ranking below weighs third-party evidence first, formula transparency second, and real per-ounce value third. Prices are approximate US online prices checked against Chewy and brand listings in 2026 and will move.

1. Petsmile Professional — the VOHC-accepted benchmark

Petsmile Professional Pet Toothpaste is the pick when a current VOHC-accepted plaque claim is the deciding factor. The dog list recognizes it for plaque, and that wording is precise: the acceptance covers the finished product for a specific claim, not every marketing sentence on the box. It uses Calprox rather than an enzyme system, comes in rotisserie chicken, London broil, and cheese flavors, and is free from fluoride, sulfates, parabens, and silica.

The catch is price and packaging. A 4.2-ounce tube with a dual-ended brush runs about $37 at Chewy, and the paste-only 4.2-ounce tube sits around $25. Per ounce, it is the premium end of the category. That is the cost of the seal. Whether the seal is worth it depends on whether you will actually brush daily. A VOHC-accepted tube that stays in the drawer loses to a cheap tube that gets used.

2. Virbac C.E.T. Enzymatic — the named dual-enzyme workhorse

Virbac C.E.T. is the vet-favorite enzymatic paste and the clearest formula disclosure in the category. It names glucose oxidase, lactoperoxidase, and potassium thiocyanate, and the poultry flavor is mild enough that many mint-averse dogs accept it. A 2.5-ounce tube is about $11.89 to $12.29 at Chewy, roughly $4.92 per ounce.

Here is the detail that gets lost in the “best enzymatic dog toothpaste” conversation: Virbac C.E.T. toothpaste is not on the current VOHC accepted-products list. Virbac's VOHC-listed dental products are its C.E.T. Veggiedent chews and Aquadent water additive, not the paste. That does not prove the paste is ineffective. It means “VOHC-accepted” is the wrong phrase for it, and a named enzyme system is a different kind of evidence from a finished-product seal. If you want the most transparent enzyme story, this is the tube. If you want the seal, keep reading.

3. Tartar Shield Pro Care — the other VOHC-accepted paste

Tartar Shield Pro Care Natural Pet Toothpaste is the quiet second VOHC toothpaste on the dog list, accepted for tartar rather than plaque. It is a coconut-flavored, human-grade-ingredient formula sold as a kit with a brush, typically around $21 to $26 depending on the retailer. It won a 2026 Veterinary Practice News Readers' Choice award, which is a popularity signal rather than a clinical one, but it confirms the product is being used in clinics.

The tartar-versus-plaque distinction is worth understanding. Plaque is the soft, sticky biofilm you can disrupt with a brush. Tartar is calcified plaque that has hardened onto the tooth. A toothpaste accepted for tartar control is making a claim about slowing that hardening, not about dissolving existing calculus. No paste removes established tartar. That requires a professional cleaning.

4. Sentry Petrodex Veterinary Strength — best value per ounce

Sentry Petrodex Veterinary Strength Enzymatic Toothpaste is the value play for a savory-flavor dog and a multi-dog household. The 6.2-ounce poultry tube runs about $9.94 at Chewy, roughly $1.60 per ounce, and the 2.5-ounce version is about $4.99. It is labeled enzymatic, but the accessible product information does not identify the enzyme system as clearly as Virbac does, and it is not on the current VOHC dog list.

That is not a scandal. Petrodex earns its place on flavor, package size, and price per ounce — the three things that determine whether a brushing routine survives a busy week. If you are brushing two Labradors and a foster, the math on a $1.60-per-ounce tube is hard to argue with. Just do not call it VOHC-accepted.

5. Arm & Hammer Complete Care — the budget large tube

Arm & Hammer Complete Care Enzymatic Dog Toothpaste is the lowest-cost large tube in the US market. A 6.2-ounce chicken tube is about $6.99 at Chewy, or roughly $1.13 per ounce. The formula is enzymatic with baking soda and calcium, fluoride-free, and designed to be swallowed without rinsing. It is a sensible entry point for an owner building a daily habit and a sensible bulk buy for a household with more than one dog.

The evidence boundary is visible. It is not on the current VOHC dog list, and baking soda on the label is not proof of superior plaque control. What it has going for it is price and acceptance. A $7 tube that gets used every night beats a $25 tube that gets used twice. That is not a compromise on dental health. It is a compromise on bragging rights.

6. Vet's Best Enzymatic Gel — best gel texture

Vet's Best Enzymatic Dog Toothpaste is a gel rather than a paste, which makes it easier to rub onto the teeth with a finger during the acclimation phase. The ingredient list includes aloe, pectin, neem oil, grapefruit seed extract, baking soda, and glucose oxidase, so the enzyme mechanism is more transparent than a vague “enzymatic” label. A 3.5-ounce bottle is about $9.53 at Chewy, roughly $2.72 per ounce.

The label suggests two to three times weekly, while veterinary dental guidelines set daily brushing as the stronger plaque-control target. Follow your veterinarian's advice when those directions differ, but understand the gap: a gel that is used three times a week is not the same routine as a paste used daily. The texture is the selling point. The frequency is the caveat.

7. Nylabone Advanced Oral Care — the cheap starter tube

Nylabone Advanced Oral Care is the impulse-purchase tube at the pet store counter and a perfectly reasonable first paste. A 2.5-ounce tube is about $7.08 at Chewy, roughly $2.84 per ounce, and the line includes tartar control, peanut butter, and original flavors. It uses Denta-C enzyme technology, but it is not VOHC-accepted, and the enzyme disclosure is less detailed than Virbac's.

Where Nylabone earns a mention is the kit. The Nylabone Advanced Oral Care Dental Kit pairs a 2.5-ounce tube with a brush for around $8 to $12 depending on the retailer, which is the cheapest way to test whether your dog will tolerate the whole ritual before you spend premium money. If the dog hates it, you are out the price of a sandwich. If the dog tolerates it, you upgrade the paste later.

Dog Toothpaste Comparison Table

Product Type VOHC status (dog toothpaste list) Size / flavor Approx. price Approx. per-ounce Best for
Petsmile Professional Non-enzymatic, Calprox Accepted for plaque 4.2 oz, rotisserie chicken ~$25 paste; ~$37 with brush ~$5.96 Evidence-first buyers
Virbac C.E.T. Enzymatic Dual-enzyme (glucose oxidase + lactoperoxidase) Not listed 2.5 oz, poultry ~$11.89–$12.29 ~$4.92 Transparent enzyme formula
Tartar Shield Pro Care Natural, VOHC-accepted Accepted for tartar 3 oz, coconut (kit) ~$21–$26 kit ~$7–$8.70 Tartar-focused routine
Sentry Petrodex Enzymatic Not listed 6.2 oz, poultry ~$9.94 ~$1.60 Multi-dog value
Arm & Hammer Complete Care Enzymatic + baking soda Not listed 6.2 oz, chicken ~$6.99 ~$1.13 Budget daily habit
Vet's Best Enzymatic Gel Gel, glucose oxidase Not listed 3.5 oz, botanical ~$9.53 ~$2.72 Finger-application acclimation
Nylabone Advanced Oral Care Enzymatic (Denta-C) Not listed 2.5 oz, peanut/original ~$7.08 ~$2.84 Cheap starter tube

Read the per-ounce column before the tube price. A 2.5-ounce tube at $12 and a 6.2-ounce tube at $10 are not the same purchase, and the smaller tube may cost more per brushing session. The comparison is not perfect because paste density varies, but it gets you closer than the shelf price. The other column to read is VOHC status, and read it carefully: “accepted for plaque” and “accepted for tartar” are different claims, and “not listed” is not a synonym for “bad.” It is a synonym for “the evidence is on the label, not on a third-party list.”

Puppy Toothpaste: When to Start and What to Change

You can start puppy dental care as early as 8 weeks old, according to veterinary guidance, by gently brushing with a dog-friendly brush and a canine toothpaste. The goal at that age is not a perfect plaque score. It is teaching the puppy that having its muzzle handled and its teeth touched is normal. A puppy toothpaste is the same idea in a milder flavor and a smaller tube. Arm & Hammer sells a coconut-mint puppy paste and a tartar-control puppy training kit with a vanilla-ginger paste and a finger brush, both designed to make the first weeks a positive experience rather than a restraint exercise.

What changes when the puppy grows up is not the safety rule. It is the brush and the flavor. Puppy teeth are smaller and the gums are more tender, so a soft finger brush or a very small headed brush is the right tool. The permanent teeth arrive around six months, and that is when the brushing routine should already be established rather than introduced. A puppy who has been licking paste off a finger since eight weeks does not need to be convinced at six months. That is the entire point of starting early.

Do not use human toothpaste on a puppy for the same reason you do not use it on an adult dog, only more so. A small body means a smaller toxic dose. Xylitol is dangerous at lower absolute amounts for a five-pound puppy than for a fifty-pound adult, and puppies are less reliable about spitting (which is to say, they do not spit at all). The cheap puppy kit from a pet store is a better purchase than the human toothpaste in the bathroom cabinet. That sentence should not need to exist. It does.

Dog Toothpaste for Sensitive Teeth and Sensitive Gums

Sensitive teeth and sensitive gums are not the same problem, and the toothpaste aisle does not always distinguish them. A dog with worn enamel or exposed dentin may flinch at a firm brush or a gritty paste. A dog with inflamed gums may bleed at the gum line and associate the brush with pain. In both cases, the first move is a veterinary exam, not a gentler tube. Brushing visibly inflamed, bleeding, or painful gums without veterinary advice can make the dog harder to brush later.

Once a veterinarian has cleared the mouth, the practical adjustments are texture, flavor, and pressure. Gel formulas like Vet's Best are easier to apply with a finger and less gritty than a paste, which can help a dog that dislikes the sensation of bristles. A soft-bristled dog brush or a finger brush is less abrasive than a firm brush. A mild poultry or coconut flavor is less likely to trigger a rejection than mint. None of those changes treat an underlying dental problem. They make the routine possible while the veterinary plan addresses the cause.

There is no US dog toothpaste that carries a VOHC acceptance specifically for “sensitive teeth.” The seal covers plaque or tartar claims, not sensitivity. That means the sensitive-teeth shopper is choosing on texture and tolerance, not on a third-party sensitivity claim. Be skeptical of a package that implies otherwise. A gel that the dog accepts is a win. A marketing claim that the dog cannot feel is not.

Plaque, Tartar, and What Toothpaste Can Realistically Fix

Plaque is a soft biofilm. It forms daily, and a brush disrupts it. Tartar is plaque that has mineralized onto the tooth surface. It is hard, it is visible, and no toothpaste removes it. The distinction is the most important thing to understand before you buy a “dog tartar toothpaste,” because the phrase is doing a lot of work that the product cannot do. A tartar-control paste can slow the hardening process. It cannot dissolve a brown ridge that has been on the molar for a year.

The evidence for plaque control is strongest when the product has a finished-product claim. Petsmile is VOHC-accepted for plaque; Tartar Shield Pro Care is accepted for tartar; Dentalis Canine Toothpaste is accepted for plaque. Those three names are the short list of toothpastes on the dog side of the VOHC directory, and even that list changes as products are added or delisted. Virbac C.E.T., Arm & Hammer, Sentry Petrodex, and Vet's Best are not listed as toothpastes, which is a statement about their VOHC status, not a statement that they do nothing.

If your goal is “best dog toothpaste for plaque,” the honest answer is that daily brushing with a soft brush and a paste the dog accepts does more than any single formula choice. The paste adds a chemical assist and makes the brush tolerable. The brush removes the biofilm. A VOHC-accepted paste gives you a documented claim for the chemical assist. It does not replace the brush, and it does not replace the veterinary cleaning that removes established tartar. The dogs that benefit most from brushing are small breeds and dogs with crowded teeth, but large dogs benefit too — for breath and for gum health.

Homemade Dog Toothpaste: What the Recipes Get Right and Wrong

Homemade dog toothpaste usually starts with coconut oil and baking soda. A typical recipe combines a quarter cup of coconut oil with two tablespoons of baking soda and a little yogurt or dog-safe flavoring, mixed into a paste and stored in a small jar. Coconut oil has mild antibacterial properties and gives the paste a texture that spreads. Baking soda adds mild abrasion. Neither ingredient is a substitute for a VOHC-accepted plaque claim, and the recipe is not standardized, which means the concentration and the pH can vary from batch to batch.

The bigger risk is the add-ins. Essential oils, concentrated mint, salt, and abrasive powders are not automatically safe because they came from a kitchen. Some essential oils are toxic to dogs, and a strong mint or cinnamon oil can irritate the mouth and make the dog refuse the brush. The VCA specifically warns against plain baking soda as a toothpaste alternative because of its alkalinity and taste. A small amount inside a commercial formula is different from a spoonful from the pantry. If you are going to make a homemade paste, keep it to a simple coconut-oil-and-baking-soda base, skip the essential oils, and ask your veterinarian before using it on a puppy, a small dog, or a dog with a sensitive stomach.

The honest case for homemade paste is cost and ingredient control, not superior cleaning. If your dog will not tolerate a commercial paste and will tolerate a coconut-oil base, a homemade paste that gets used is better than a commercial tube that does not. But do not mistake “no preservatives” for “safer.” A jar of coconut oil and baking soda sitting on the counter for a week is a microbial science experiment with a pleasant smell. Make small batches, refrigerate, and throw it out when it smells off.

Dog Toothpaste and Brush Kits: What You Actually Need

The kit is the unit that makes the habit. A tube without a brush is a tube you will not use, and a brush without a paste the dog accepts is a wrestling match. The US market sells three practical configurations. The Virbac C.E.T. Oral Hygiene Kit pairs a 2.5-ounce poultry paste with a dual-ended brush and a finger brush for around $15, which is the most common starter kit in veterinary clinics. The Arm & Hammer Complete Care Dental Kit pairs a 2.5-ounce tube with a double-sided brush and a finger brush for around $5 to $7 at mass retail, which is the cheapest way to test the whole ritual. The Nylabone kit is similar and sits in the same price band.

What you do not need is a $40 electric toothbrush for a dog that has never had its muzzle handled. The brush is a delivery tool for friction and paste, not a gadget. A soft-bristled brush with a head small enough for the dog's mouth and an angled handle is enough. A finger brush is useful in the first two weeks because it lets you control pressure and feel the gum line. A dual-ended brush with a small head on one end and a larger head on the other covers a Chihuahua and a Labrador in the same household. The rest is technique and repetition.

One more kit note: the brush should be replaced when the bristles splay, roughly every three months with daily use. The paste should be checked for an expiration date. Expired dog toothpaste usually will not hurt the dog, but it may taste less appealing and work less well, which defeats the purpose of buying a paste the dog likes in the first place.

How to Brush a Dog's Teeth Without a Wrestling Match

The first session should not involve teeth. It should involve a finger and a dab of paste. Let the dog lick the paste off your finger and stop. Do that for a few days until the dog associates the tube with a treat. Then wrap a gauze pad or a finger brush around your finger, add a little paste, and gently rub the outer surfaces of the front teeth and along the gum line. The outer surfaces are the priority because the tongue keeps the inner surfaces relatively clean, and the gum line is where plaque does the most damage.

Once the dog accepts the finger, move to a soft brush. Put the paste between the bristles rather than on top, so the paste spends more time against the teeth and gums as the brush moves. Brush in small circles at the gum line, front to back, for a few seconds per section. Do not force the mouth open and do not saw at the teeth. The goal is to disrupt the plaque film, not to scrub enamel. Most of the benefit comes from consistency, not from duration. Daily is best; every other day is the realistic fallback.

If the dog has painful gums, stop and see a veterinarian. If the dog has a history of guarding its mouth or has bitten during handling, work with a trainer or veterinary behaviorist rather than pushing through. A dental routine that ends in a bite is a routine that will not happen. The dogs that benefit most from brushing are small breeds and dogs with crowded teeth, but the handling tolerance has to come first. A dog that will let you lift its lip and touch a finger to a molar is a dog you can brush. Build that before you worry about the back molars.

Can you use toothpaste on a dog?

Only dog-specific toothpaste. Human toothpaste can contain xylitol, which is toxic to dogs and can cause hypoglycemia, seizures, and liver failure, and it may contain fluoride and foaming agents that a dog cannot spit out. A dog toothpaste is designed to be swallowed in small amounts and comes in flavors a dog will accept.

What is the best dog toothpaste for plaque?

The strongest third-party evidence in the US market belongs to Petsmile Professional, which carries a current VOHC acceptance for plaque on the dog list. Tartar Shield Pro Care is accepted for tartar, and Dentalis Canine Toothpaste is accepted for plaque. Virbac C.E.T. has a clearly disclosed dual-enzyme system but is not on the current VOHC toothpaste list. Daily brushing matters more than the brand.

Is enzymatic dog toothpaste better than regular dog toothpaste?

It depends on the formula, not the word. Virbac C.E.T. names glucose oxidase and lactoperoxidase, which is a transparent dual-enzyme system. Petsmile uses a non-enzymatic calcium peroxide formula and holds a VOHC plaque claim. “Enzymatic” on a label is a category word, not proof of a specific enzyme, concentration, or tested finished product.

Can I use human toothpaste for my dog just once?

Do not. A single exposure to a xylitol-containing toothpaste can cause a rapid insulin release and life-threatening hypoglycemia in a dog, and the risk is higher for a small dog or puppy. If your dog accidentally swallows human toothpaste, call your veterinarian or an animal poison-control service rather than waiting for symptoms.

How do you make dog toothpaste at home?

A simple base is about a quarter cup of coconut oil mixed with two tablespoons of baking soda, with no essential oils or added salt. Keep batches small, refrigerate, and discard when it smells off. Homemade paste is not standardized and has no VOHC claim, and plain baking soda alone can upset a dog's stomach, so ask your veterinarian before using it on a puppy or a dog with sensitivities.

What is the best dog toothpaste for puppies?

The best puppy toothpaste is a dog-specific paste in a mild flavor that the puppy will lick from a finger, paired with a finger brush. Arm & Hammer sells a coconut-mint puppy paste and a vanilla-ginger puppy training kit, and the Virbac C.E.T. kit is a common clinic starter. Start around 8 weeks with taste and touch, not with a full brushing session.

Do I need a toothpaste and brush kit, or can I buy them separately?

A kit is the cheaper way to start because it removes the guesswork about brush size and paste flavor. The Virbac C.E.T. Oral Hygiene Kit and the Arm & Hammer Complete Care Dental Kit both pair a small tube with a brush and a finger brush for roughly $5 to $15. Once you know the dog's preferred flavor and brush size, buying the paste in a larger tube is more economical per ounce.

Whats the best dog toothpaste if my dog hates mint?

Skip mint. Poultry, beef, peanut butter, vanilla-ginger, and coconut flavors are all common in the US market, and a savory paste is more likely to be accepted by a dog that turns away from a minty smell. Virbac C.E.T. poultry, Sentry Petrodex poultry, and Nylabone peanut are the practical starting points. A paste the dog accepts twice a day beats a “better” paste the dog refuses.